• Welcome back Guest!

    MARSH is a private reefing group. Comments and suggestions are encouraged, but please keep them positive and constructive. Negative threads, posts, or attacks will be removed from view and reviewed by the staff. Continually disruptive, argumentative, or flagrant rule breakers may be suspended or banned.

Nano LifeSpan questions (1 Viewer)

  • Thread starter Guest
  • Start date
  • Tagged users None

Users who are viewing this thread

G

Guest

Just a few questions for nano reef owners:

Has anyone owned their nano for over a year?

How long has your coral lasted?

How often do you check your parameters?

How often do you do water changes and add top off?

What size is your nano?

How big is your bio-load?

Thanks for stopping and answering these questions.

mike
 
OP
OP
G

Guest

with nanos you have to keep up on the water changes. One every week. you would want to test for every thing that you do in a big tank. I have some corals that i have moved from nano to nano and all have done well. my 20 has been up for over a year but i swaped out for a drilled 20. for my bio-load Im just getting to where i want fish. Top off i just add a cup of RO water every 2 days.
 

Aggie05

Guest
Joined
Oct 13, 2003
Messages
229
Reaction score
0
Location
Seabrook
I had a 20 long set up for close to two years that I took down because I was moving. It was full of coral and contained a minimum of two fish throughout its life. I never had problems with it and it was the most beautiful tank I have ever owned. Water changes are a must and topoffs as well, other than that, its pretty standard. Here is a pic just for good memories.
 

Aggie05

Guest
Joined
Oct 13, 2003
Messages
229
Reaction score
0
Location
Seabrook
I had a 20 long set up for close to two years that I took down because I was moving. It was full of coral and contained a minimum of two fish throughout its life. I never had problems with it and it was the most beautiful tank I have ever owned. Water changes are a must and topoffs as well, other than that, its pretty standard. Here is a pic just for good memories.
 

Aggie05

Guest
Joined
Oct 13, 2003
Messages
229
Reaction score
0
Location
Seabrook
I just realized I didn't answer all your questions.

Water changes were done every two weeks, two gallons at a time.

I checked my paramaters never. Except for salinity.

I had an auto top off system that kicked on once a day.

Hope that helps.
 

incysor

Guest
Joined
Sep 15, 2003
Messages
1,157
Reaction score
0
Location
Central Houston/Heights
Metsuko said:
Just a few questions for nano reef owners:

Has anyone owned their nano for over a year?

How long has your coral lasted?

How often do you check your parameters?

How often do you do water changes and add top off?

What size is your nano?

How big is your bio-load?

Thanks for stopping and answering these questions.

mike

My 6g work nano has been up for about 18 months now.

Just like larger tanks I've lost a few things, but mostly it's done very well, and I have nearly all the things I started with.

I haven't ever tested my parameters. I started it with half new water and half water from my larger system. I added rock and sand from my existing system as well. I've never had a bunch of stuff look unhappy, so I haven't tested it.

I've got an auto topoff on it. I add about a 1/2 gallon of new RO/DI water to this once a week. I do a 1g water change EVERY week. If I screw up and forget, I do a 2g water change, then do another one the following week. I use saltwater I buy from PlanetFish, or VTF on my lunch break. I don't use any supplements on this tank at all.

I've only changed the filter twice in the entire time I've had the tank up.

I've only changed the airstone 4-5 times.

The bioload for the first month was coral, hermits and snails.
I added a harlequin shrimp, and a pair of sexy shrimp in the second month.
My pair of occellaris were added either on end of the 4th month or sometime in the 5th.
About 6 weeks ago I added a seahorse.

This forum is great, but I get more specific info on nanos from
www.nanotank.com
and
www.nano-reef.com

Good luck, and take pics. :wink:

B
 
OP
OP
G

Guest

Thanks guys. Well i was just curious and wanted to know if it is a lot of trouble to keep a mini/nano-reef tank. I had purchased a nano from pam before the summer and had setup a FOWLR for my wife. But i guess i have been lucky becuase i have only done 2 water changes the entire time, but the only thing that i have in it now is a few hermit crabs and a toby that seems to be doing very well. but i just wanted to know a few thing and see if i should down size my 45 to a 20 or smaller tank. i guess i will have to wait and see if it is worth it or not, i really want to setup something right the first time to create a mini self reliant eco system, without that much maintaince. thanks for the info guys.

mike
 

equinecpa

Guest
Joined
Sep 20, 2005
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
My pair of occellaris were added either on end of the 4th month or sometime in the 5th.
About 6 weeks ago I added a seahorse.

Did I read that right? A pair of clowns and a seahorse in a 6 gallon? How are they getting along? You've broken many rules of seahorse keeping in one go, so I'm wondering how your keeping everything healthy and happy? 6 gallons is considered too small for a seahorse tank, clowns are touch and go as tankmates, and gosh your probably overstocked too!

Don't take this as bashing. I raise Erectus seahorses and everything I have ever read says they need bigger tanks.
 

incysor

Guest
Joined
Sep 15, 2003
Messages
1,157
Reaction score
0
Location
Central Houston/Heights
Carolyn

Yes. You counted correctly.

I always overstock my tanks.

Before I moved my 55g reef had 15 fish in it. For over 2yrs.

My 75g has nearly that many now. It's been up and running for a year and a half, with no problems.

I attribute being able to keep systems stable and happy with this many fish, to researching the needs of the animals, and mainly stocking smaller fish, and non-agressive species. I certainly wouldn't try this with tangs, and dottybacks. :)

The 6g has been running for over a year with everything except the seahorse. It's more stable, and maintenance free than any other tank I've had.

I understand that seahorses have special needs. I'm on the forums at seahorse.org, and have researched them pretty well, Although there's always room for more research/learning.

I'm generally not an impulse buyer when it comes to the aquariums.

I also think that a lot of the 'rules' for keeping healthy/happy aquariums are pretty fluid. The more delicate, or difficult a coral/critter is the more rigid the thinking seems to become. I wouldn't have put a seahorse in with tomato clowns, or maroon clowns, but these are occellaris, which tend to be much less agressive, and I've kept a very close eye on them. (Remember this is my work tank, so I can look at it 8-10hrs a day 5-6 days a week). If they'd acted agressively towards the pony I would have removed it immediately. I have another tank that's been up and running for a year and a half, that doesn't have anything except some rock, a couple mushrooms and a small cabbage leather in it, that I could remove it too. The reason I didn't choose that tank initially is because I can monitor this one more closely, and it has a much lower flowrate than the larger one. If I see that it's not doing well, I'll move it and address the flow issue. So far, over the last 6-7wks it's been eating well, and swims around the lower portion of the tank were there's even less flow than in the rest of the tank and the clowns haven't shown even the slightest interest in it.

B
 

equinecpa

Guest
Joined
Sep 20, 2005
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
That's really interesting. Marc over at DFWMAS is keeping a reidi in a 2.5 Pico!

I agree with you that with diligent monitering a lot of rules can probably be broken. Not a wise idea for the masses but for those who will take time and are careful it probably is OK.

I had someone looking to buy a couple of my seahorses to put in a 12 nano cube - I didn't sell them for fear of them being unhappy (they are currently in a 30 gallon).

Carolyn
 
OP
OP
G

Guest

I don't have a nano at all, but I am interested in everything to do with this hobby, so I was facinated to read about incysor keeping a seahorse with his clown. As some of you know, I've been breaking down and selling my 125 reef in preparation for moving-which includes selling a Ocellaris clown that I've had for 3 years. I plan on moving my 90 gallon dedicated seahorse tank to Colorado with us. I have a total of 6 seahorses, and the only fish I keep in there is a goby to eat the leftovers....
I never imagined that I could possibly keep a clown with them. Interesting....maybe I won't sell him after all.... :)
seahorse.com is also a hang-out of mine...
 

incysor

Guest
Joined
Sep 15, 2003
Messages
1,157
Reaction score
0
Location
Central Houston/Heights
FWIW, I decided that the seahorse wasn't able to swim around well in my tank, and turned it into the LFS. It was eating well, and the clowns didn't bother it, but there simply wasn't a lot of open room for it to swim around free of the corals.

B
 
OP
OP
G

Guest

Aggie05 said:
I just realized I didn't answer all your questions.

Water changes were done every two weeks, two gallons at a time.

I checked my paramaters never. Except for salinity.

I had an auto top off system that kicked on once a day.

Hope that helps.

I am changing more like almost 5 gal at a time in my 20 do you think that is too much?
 

incysor

Guest
Joined
Sep 15, 2003
Messages
1,157
Reaction score
0
Location
Central Houston/Heights
Reefaholic1980 said:
I am changing more like almost 5 gal at a time in my 20 do you think that is too much?

A 25% water change is usually something that's done to fix a problem.

That large a change can be a bit of a shock, if temp, salinity, ph, are significantly different between the tank water and the new water. However if they're close it shouldn't really be a problem.

Is this a weekly water change? I shoot for 10-15% as a weekly water change. If I had to skip a week, or if I've found my params are out of whack I've moved it up to the 25-30% mark, but been careful to add the new water in over the course of a couple hours to give everything time to adjust to it.

B
 
Top