What's wrong with the home depot shingles just curious? Aren't the contractors get it from the same place less discounted?
Two family members went through home depot after Hurricane Harvey - shingles total package was under ~$5k and roof company labor was another ~$3k if I'm not mistaken. These are standard two story homes. So far so good - no complaints.
I"m sure prices are way higher now post Covid.
So it comes down to the manufacture process and the materials used. After roofing for over 20 years I’ve had the chance to get hands on experience with the majority of shingle brands out there. They ALL have different areas that they focus on which directly affects the end product.
OC was known for their Sure Nail as it was very wide in comparison to other brands, (this being the area the nails are to go, which is supposed to be the area of double layer). As far as granule retention, delamination, wind ratings etc; OC is a sub par shingle. I provide ANY shingle that a customer may request/require, that said those who listen to me get the best. In my professional opinion that is Certainteed. This is a better all around shingle with a 50 year NON-PRORATED warranty! I bet and build my company on this brand.
That’s not to say that Jonnie on the spot won’t say that OC is king because he may not have access to supply houses that have certain requirements.
I tell everyone that asks, you don’t have to use me but be very careful who you choose. I constantly run behind larger companies along with smaller ones and see where these companies are lacking, not to mention the “roofers” installing! Saving money at the time is NEVER a good idea when it comes to your roofing system, you do get what you pay for! With 10 minutes I almost guarantee I’d find at least 3 things wrong with most roofs…and the funny thing is it’s usually minor details that cause major issues!